[Burichan] [Desudesudesu] [Photon] [Gurochan] [Futaba] [Tomorrow] - [Home] [RSS Live Feed] [Manage]

Posting mode: Reply
Leave these fields empty (spam trap):
Password (for post and file deletion and editing)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG
  • Maximum file size allowed is 10240 KB.
  • Images greater than 250x250 pixels will be thumbnailed.

File: 1315716721386.png -(319.5 KiB, 480x640) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.
327202 No.2268   [Delete]   [Edit

Here are the results for Shinku:

  • Cpt. Jean-Luc Picard (Star Trek) [disqualified]
  • Kyuubey (Puella Magi Madoka Magica) - 13
  • Reinhard von Lohengramm (Legend of Galactic Heroes) - 4

Kyuubey is the winner! Thank you for voting.

To those who voted for Picard, my sincere apologies. I seriously don't know how we got this past the radar, and it's quite frustrating having to disqualify Picard myself.

Last edited by moderator 11/09/11(Sun)00:52.

>> No.2269   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312313650299.jpg -(111.1 KiB, 400x300) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Voting for Reinhard. Just think about it, they are a perfect match!

Pic related.

>> No.2270   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2271   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312314860772.jpg -(69.9 KiB, 813x668) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Going for the Kyuubey here.

>> No.2272   [Delete]   [Edit]

Kyubey....or however you spell his name. There's at least 4 or 5 different ways. @[email protected]

>> No.2273   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312315766792.jpg -(1.4 MiB, 2006x2884) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Who do you think?

>> No.2274   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312331450644.gif -(2.2 MiB, 360x270) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Captain, Jean-luc picard of the U.S.S. Enterprise...

>> No.2275   [Delete]   [Edit]

+1 Picard. They're both REDshirts, amirite?

>> No.2276   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2277   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312342628068.jpg -(40.2 KiB, 301x300) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Of course Kyuubey, a lot of potential there, even more if Hina becomes Madoka.

>> No.2278   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2279   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2280   [Delete]   [Edit]

Reinhard, definitly.

>> No.2283   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2287   [Delete]   [Edit]

Cpt. Jean-Luc Picard

>> No.2288   [Delete]   [Edit]

Vote for Picard

>> No.2289   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312559239632.jpg -(16.2 KiB, 275x206) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

I must cast my vote for QB.

>> No.2290   [Delete]   [Edit]

oh, man. picard and kyuubey...

picard D:

>> No.2291   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1312656963499.jpg -(476.5 KiB, 750x1061) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Stupid sexy Kyuubey

>> No.2292   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2295   [Delete]   [Edit]

+1 Picard

>> No.2300   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2301   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2302   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1313963189476.png -(248.9 KiB, 640x640) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Voting for Kyuubey means voting for the good of humanity, more so than Picard. +1 Kyuubey.

This post is sponsored by Kyuubey.

>> No.2303   [Delete]   [Edit]

A vote for Kyuubey is a vote for a better future.

>> No.2306   [Delete]   [Edit]

Kyuubey KyuBey QB

>> No.2307   [Delete]   [Edit]

Voting for CP
Fuck kyuubey.

>> No.2308   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1314424172925.jpg -(13.3 KiB, 502x512) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Okay, I am gonna change my vote here just to tip the voting in QB's favor. Why? Because I realized if Picard wins this, the end result will be indistinguishable from the sucker in this image, due to starfleet uniforms.

In short, if you're voting Picard, you could just as well be voting for this fucker due to uniforms.

>> No.2309   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1314470861398.gif -(78.6 KiB, 650x450) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.


>> No.2310   [Delete]   [Edit]

Seriously speaking while looking back, I don't know how we could get Picard past the rules radar. Unfortunately, while I felt I'm leaving it this late, I will have to disqualify Picard.

Those who voted for Picard are welcome to change your votes. Voting will be extended until September 10.

Last edited by moderator 11/08/28(Sun)09:54.

>> No.2311   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1314548177785.jpg -(72.1 KiB, 512x730) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Still sticking with Maetel...

>> No.2312   [Delete]   [Edit]

I still don't really see why, sure his uniform looks like most of the rest of the crews, but you still don't instantly think of Wesley, you think of Picard. (In fact, since the uniforms also are color coded, only a few others such as Wesley have uniforms identical to Picards)

>> No.2313   [Delete]   [Edit]

A uniform is still a uniform, meaning that there is no way to distinguish it from any other character from the same series that happen to wear the same type of uniform. The only way to identify that that is actually supposed to be Picard's uniform in the resulting art is the amount of dots on the uniform's collar, which in itself not many take note of. And making her bald just to increase the resemblance just doesn't count it. Hamuleen is not about the hairstyles, it's about the costumes, and for a damn good reason too.

>> No.2314   [Delete]   [Edit]


...oh, nevermind.


>> No.2315   [Delete]   [Edit]


+1 Kyuubey, as she's the only obvious choice after Starfleet redshirts.

>> No.2316   [Delete]   [Edit]


>> No.2317   [Delete]   [Edit]

>>2316 see >>2310

>> No.2321   [Delete]   [Edit]

So... has any Maiden, or at lest Shinku, actually been drawn in that type of uniform? I get the generic costume rule (which seems to me like a rule that serves the same purpose of the "can't pick one that's already been drawn at some point rule" because it encourages originality), but if it's never actually been done in any form isn't it still original? I mean shit, aren't there tons of characters who wear uniforms? Can't the generic costume ruling come into effect only if the uniform type has already been used once?

Is there some magical force that prevents us from improving upon someone else's original rules or at least making reasonable judgements on when we should and should not enforce the rules to a T?

Last edited 11/09/09(Fri)15:22.

>> No.2322   [Delete]   [Edit]

For your interest, we just recently got the green from Aphex (who used to host this entire event, including drawing the winners) to change the rules to accomondate any new developments that are nessecary. So there is nothing preventing us from changing or removing the Generic Costume rule if needed.

On the other hand, the generic costume rule is there for a DAMN good reason. What we are trying to put forward are CHARACTER outfits, and if the outfit suggested is near completely identical to the outfit worn by the majority of the cast in the show, there is little to no way of actually identifying the outfit as what it is intended to be. It's beyond the point if the outfit itself has been drawn or not, it still goes against the main spirit of Hamuleen. Hamuleen is about drawing the Rozen Maiden characters in outfits iconic to characters from other franchises, not simply outfits that are iconic to the setting.

And is it just me, but are you simply going around the boards to question the rules that exist simply to get your favorite finalists back into the ballot?

>> No.2323   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1315626362246.jpg -(152.0 KiB, 791x604) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

A Shinku/Picard could work with the idea that in the pic the regular bridge crew would be in there as well, just to force home what its supposed to be.

This crude mockup would be the general idea.

>> No.2324   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1315628135279.jpg -(57.1 KiB, 476x360) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

Oh for the love of... It's too late to try to un-disqualify him anyway, so stop trying to be a fucking defence force. Rules are rules, and I highly doubt even with that suggestiong that Wingless will put him back just one day before voting ends. We do not need to pull the voting out further, dammit, if we actually want ANYTHING this year.

Pic related, oh yes, you better believe it is related.

>> No.2326   [Delete]   [Edit]
File: 1315631728079.jpg -(198.7 KiB, 1280x1024) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.


It's my duty to defend I must say!

>> No.2327   [Delete]   [Edit]

Look, I understand your predicament, but don't wait until the absolute last moments before you raise your concerns then. We don't need to draw out the voting phase further.

Delete Post [] Password
Report Post(s) to Staff