I've been visiting desuchan since mid 2007 on and off-- I'm not quite a regular but I've been following the site and posting silently on occasion. While this thread may not be watched, I have noticed a few things that I'd like to share.
I think the most important thing to realize is that desuchan will never be as big as it once was back in its peak. There's not much that can be done about this; even S3 wouldn't bring it back to its old level-- unless someone wants to revive the practice of spamming desu everywhere, of course.
Boards need to be cut. Unless you are a behemoth like 4chan that will garner traffic irregardless of how many boards are in place, a *chan should not be overly saturated with boards, eg: iichan. The less boards there are, the more the traffic can be condensed; the more condensed the traffic is, the more active the boards appear to be. Having the illusion of "more traffic" compounded with having a more condensed list of boards attracts new posters and brings out lurkers. Just skimming through the list, I see many dead boards that have topics that could fit elsewhere: /peach/, /md/, /c/, /yan/, /pro/, /gar/, and /vic/ among others. It's nice and all that there is a /sandbox/ to try new board ideas, but it's important to trim what there is currently before adding anything else.
For the record, consolidating the maiden boards into a singular board is a horrible idea-- as said, they are part of the site's identity. On the same page, a Peach-Pit board isn't as much (unless you really want a Shugo Chara discussion that badly).
Comment too long. Click here
to view the full text.